10 million evangelicals skipped midterms: What the ‘blue wave’ means for the future

November 17, 2026

10 million evangelicals skipped midterms: What the ‘blue wave’ means for the future

‘Conservative Christians should look at this loss as a wake-up call for future elections and be informed, equipped and prepared to take back our nation at the next election’

WASHINGTON — With the 2026 midterm elections in the nation’s rearview mirror, conservative Christians are growing increasingly concerned for America’s future following the monumental “blue wave.” Democrats flipped President Trump’s previously Republican Congress thanks to widespread voter discontent, based mostly on the economy, government corruption, and the ongoing war in Iran. Analysis of voter turnout indicates that while approximately the same number of evangelicals participated in this election as in previous years, other demographics came out in full force, turning the tide for the Dems.

However, if conservative Christians truly believed the nation’s future was at stake, why did as many as 10 million evangelicals not show up? Had they participated, the results would have been different.

So, what does this mean for evangelical voters moving forward? These less-than-ideal results illustrate the importance of being informed and voting down the entire ballot, declared iVoterGuide (iVoterGuide.com) President Debbie Wuthnow. iVoterGuide is the nation’s premier Christian voting guide, offering carefully researched voter guides that outline every single candidate on the ballot to ensure educated voters at the polls.

“Before the midterm elections, iVoterGuide partnered with esteemed pollster Dr. George Barna to learn exactly how citizens view their role in the voting process, and the results were stunning in the extreme,” commented Wuthnow. “We found that one in six Americans think their votes don’t matter, resulting in many not voting all the way down the ballot or simply refraining from voting altogether. I think it’s safe to assume that this type of lackluster voting might have been at play this election season, resulting in this Democratic tidal wave that has swept the nation. What evangelical Republicans must understand is that their voice matters for every single election on the ballot — it is paramount that the conservative Christians make a stand before it’s too late.”

Barna’s research with iVoterGuide revealed that barely half of American voters vote down the ballot, abandoning the important school board, judicial and local races that most directly shape their communities. This gap in voter participation makes a clear window for opportunistic candidates, despite not perfectly reflecting the communities they represent.

“What should we take away from this midterm season?” asked Wuthnow. “Conservative Christians should look at this loss as a wake-up call for future elections and be informed, equipped and prepared to take back our nation at the next election. We cannot sit idly by, thinking that our voices can’t make a difference, when the nation we know and love becomes lost due to our own apathy.”

This midterm election, the organization reported that over 4.4 million voters were informed by iVoterGuide this year, with two and a half times more visits this midterm than for the 2024 presidential election.

For those unsure of which candidates have earned their vote, iVoterGuide.com, a division of AFA Action, provides accurate, up-to-date information on thousands of candidates. iVoterGuide.com’s research and ratings can be extremely valuable in helping voters determine the distinctions between candidates.

iVoterGuide.com is dedicated to equipping Americans to be informed, educated voters and is a one-stop resource for candidate ratings and election information. iVoterGuide.com is known for its accuracy and integrity in researching and evaluating candidates and equipping Christians to vote wisely and be good stewards of their citizenship.

Hosted by iVoterGuide President Debbie Wuthnow and Rick Beggs, “The Compass” is iVoterGuide’s weekly conversation about the issues shaping the public square — produced in partnership with American Family Radio. Each episode unpacks what’s at stake for voters of faith and where biblical principles meet the news of the week.

iVoterGuide’s public service announcements are short audio and video messages that broadcasters and voters are welcome to share. Listen here or download a copy for broadcast.

For more information on iVoterGuide.com, visit iVoterGuide.com or follow iVoterGuide.com on Facebook, X, Instagram, YouTube, or Pinterest.

###

To interview an iVoterGuide.com spokesperson, contact Hamilton Strategies, Media@HamiltonStrategies.com, Beth Bogucki, 610.584.1096 ext. 105, or Daniel Moyer, ext. 104.